Introduction
Have you ever experienced the magic of a perfect plate of pasta, the aroma of simmering tomato sauce, or the warmth of a welcoming trattoria? In Pittsburgh, these moments are not just dreams – they’re a delicious reality. Nestled amidst the city’s iconic bridges and vibrant neighborhoods lies a rich Italian culinary heritage, a legacy that has shaped the Steel City’s food scene for generations. Finding exceptional Italian dining experiences here is easier than you might think.
This isn’t just another list of restaurants; it’s a carefully curated guide to the very best Italian eateries Pittsburgh has to offer. We’ll take you on a culinary journey through neighborhood gems, fine dining establishments, and casual eateries, highlighting what makes each one truly special. Whether you’re craving a classic plate of spaghetti and meatballs, a wood-fired pizza with perfectly blistered crust, or a sophisticated seafood creation, you’ll find it here. Forget endless scrolling through online reviews; this is your definitive resource for discovering the most authentic and memorable Italian dining experiences in Pittsburgh.
Before diving into the mouthwatering details, let’s discuss how we selected these culinary champions. The “best” is, of course, subjective, but our choices are based on a rigorous evaluation process. We considered several key factors:
First, we looked for authenticity. We prioritized restaurants that use fresh, high-quality ingredients and adhere to traditional Italian cooking techniques. We sought out establishments where Nonna’s recipes are not just inspiration, but the foundation of the menu.
Next, we assessed quality. The best Italian food isn’t just about tradition; it’s about execution. We looked for restaurants that consistently deliver perfectly cooked pasta, flavorful sauces, and beautifully presented dishes.
Ambiance is another crucial element. The best Italian restaurants offer more than just great food; they provide a warm, inviting atmosphere where you can relax, connect with friends and family, and savor the moment.
Value also played a role. We considered the price point of each restaurant and whether it provided a fair return for the dining experience. A delicious meal doesn’t have to break the bank.
Finally, we paid close attention to local reputation. What do Pittsburghers themselves say about these restaurants? We scoured online reviews, listened to word-of-mouth recommendations, and considered the longevity of each establishment within the community.
With these criteria in mind, we present our guide to the best Italian restaurants in Pittsburgh. Get ready to loosen your belts and prepare your taste buds for an unforgettable experience.
The best Italian restaurants in Pittsburgh
DiAnoia’s Eatery: A Strip District Staple
Located in the heart of the Strip District, DiAnoia’s Eatery is a vibrant and bustling spot that embodies the spirit of Italian-American cuisine. This isn’t just a restaurant; it’s a neighborhood gathering place where the aroma of freshly baked bread and simmering sauces fills the air. The atmosphere is warm and inviting, with exposed brick walls, communal tables, and a lively open kitchen.
DiAnoia’s is known for its exceptional pasta dishes, made with fresh, house-made pasta and flavorful sauces. Their cacio e pepe is a must-try, a simple yet elegant dish that showcases the quality of the ingredients. They also have a beautiful selection of paninis and other Italian street food, perfect for a quick lunch or a casual dinner. One of the best things about DiAnoia’s is their commitment to supporting local farmers and producers, ensuring that every dish is made with the freshest, most seasonal ingredients. Expect to spend around fifteen to thirty-five dollars. You can find them on Penn Avenue in the Strip District. It’s one of those restaurants that makes you feel like you’re stepping into a family kitchen, a sentiment echoed in countless glowing reviews.
Sarafino’s: High Quality and Attention to Detail
Sarafino’s in Crafton boasts a wide range of Italian dishes featuring the freshest ingredients. The ambiance is sophisticated without being stuffy, making it a great place for a date night or a special occasion.
The seafood risotto is a standout, a creamy and flavorful dish that’s packed with fresh seafood. Another popular choice is the osso buco, a classic Italian braised veal shank that’s incredibly tender and flavorful. It is also worth noting that the wine list is extensive and well-curated, with a wide selection of Italian wines to complement the menu. You’re looking at around twenty to forty dollars for an entrée, a price point well worth the experience. You can find Sarafino’s on Noble Avenue in Crafton. They are often praised for their attention to detail and exceptional service.
Piccolo Forno: Bloomfield’s Authentic Gem
Piccolo Forno, nestled in the heart of Bloomfield, has gained a devoted following for its commitment to authentic Italian cuisine. The atmosphere is cozy and rustic, with exposed brick walls, wooden tables, and a warm, inviting glow.
They are particularly known for their wood-fired pizzas, cooked in a traditional brick oven and topped with fresh, high-quality ingredients. The margherita pizza is a classic choice, showcasing the simple elegance of Italian flavors. But don’t miss out on their handmade pasta dishes, prepared with seasonal ingredients and bursting with flavor. The gnocchi is a standout, light and fluffy and served with a variety of delicious sauces. Price point ranges from around fifteen to thirty dollars. Piccolo Forno is located on Penn Avenue in Bloomfield and is often touted as a “hidden gem” where people go to appreciate quality.
Girasole: A Taste of Italy in Shadyside
Girasole in Shadyside offers an elegant and upscale dining experience, focusing on Northern Italian cuisine. The atmosphere is sophisticated and romantic, with soft lighting, white tablecloths, and a refined décor.
The menu features a variety of classic Italian dishes, prepared with the finest ingredients and presented with impeccable attention to detail. The handmade pasta dishes are a highlight, with a variety of creative and flavorful sauces. Their wine list is extensive and well-curated, with a wide selection of Italian wines to complement the menu. Expect to spend upwards of thirty dollars per entree. Girasole can be found on Walnut Street in Shadyside. One reviewer wrote, “If you want to impress someone with authentic and elegant Italian, this is the place.”
Cure: Meat and Italian Delights
While not strictly *only* Italian, Cure, in Lawrenceville, earns a spot on this list for its exceptional charcuterie, many of which are Italian influenced, and rustic, Italian-inspired dishes. The atmosphere is industrial-chic, with exposed brick walls, high ceilings, and a bustling open kitchen.
Their charcuterie boards are a must-try, featuring a selection of handcrafted meats, cheeses, and accompaniments. The pasta dishes are also excellent, prepared with fresh, seasonal ingredients and bursting with flavor. Cure is a great place to enjoy a casual meal with friends or a romantic dinner for two. Expect to spend between twenty and forty dollars for most dishes. Cure is located on Butler Street in Lawrenceville, and many appreciate their emphasis on high-quality, locally sourced ingredients.
Category Breakdown
The best pizza
For the best pizza in the city, look no further than Driftwood Oven in Lawrenceville. Their sourdough crust is legendary, and they use creative and high-quality toppings. For a more traditional Neapolitan experience, Caliente Pizza House offers a wide variety of pizzas, plus Italian hoagies and more.
The best pasta
Alla Famiglia in Allentown is where you can find family-style dining that features huge portions of hand-rolled pasta. If you enjoy handmade and specialty pasta, this is a perfect destination. Be sure to come hungry!
The best seafood
Pittsburgh is not right by the ocean, but for some of the freshest takes on Italian seafood, visit Monterey Bay Fish Grotto on Mt. Washington. This upscale restaurant offers incredible views of the city along with beautifully prepared seafood dishes with an Italian flair.
The best fine dining
For an unforgettable fine dining experience, make a reservation at Altius on Mt. Washington. This restaurant offers breathtaking panoramic views of the city along with a sophisticated Italian-inspired menu. The service is impeccable, and the food is truly exceptional.
The best casual Italian
If you’re looking for a more casual and affordable Italian option, check out Pastoli’s Pizza, Pasta and Paisans in the North Hills. This family-friendly restaurant offers a wide variety of pizzas, pastas, and sandwiches, all at reasonable prices. They also have a great selection of beer and wine.
Honorable Mentions
Vallozzi’s Pittsburgh: A classic Italian restaurant in downtown Pittsburgh, known for its elegant atmosphere and traditional dishes.
Il Pizzaiolo: A popular spot in Market Square, serving up authentic Neapolitan pizzas and other Italian specialties.
Joseph Tambellini Restaurant: A longstanding restaurant specializing in fine Italian dining with a warm ambiance.
Tips for Dining in Pittsburgh’s Italian Restaurants
Reservations are highly recommended, especially on weekends. Many of these restaurants are popular and fill up quickly.
Don’t be afraid to ask your server for recommendations. They can often point you towards the best dishes and hidden gems on the menu.
Consider trying some local Italian wines. Pennsylvania has a growing wine industry, and many local wineries produce excellent Italian-style wines.
Be aware that parking can be challenging in some of the more popular neighborhoods. Consider using public transportation or a ride-sharing service.
Most importantly, be open to trying new things and exploring the diverse flavors of Pittsburgh’s Italian cuisine.
Conclusion
Pittsburgh’s Italian food scene is a testament to the city’s rich cultural heritage and its love of good food. From classic red-sauce joints to sophisticated fine-dining establishments, there’s something for everyone to enjoy. So, gather your friends and family, embark on a culinary adventure, and discover your own favorite Italian restaurant in Pittsburgh. With so many incredible options to choose from, you’re sure to find a meal that will leave you saying “bellissimo!” Now it is your turn to experience these Italian dining locations and share your adventures. What are you waiting for?
