Introduction
Picture this: the aroma of freshly baked bread mingling with the salty tang of the sea air. This isn’t a scene from a quaint Italian village; it’s a snapshot of 86th Street in Bay Ridge, Brooklyn. More than just a thoroughfare, 86th Street is the vibrant heart of this waterfront neighborhood, a bustling hub where old-world charm meets modern-day living. While known for its diverse shops and easy access to the R train, 86th Street truly shines as a food lover’s paradise.
If you’re on the hunt for incredible food on 86th Street, you’re in for a treat. From classic Italian eateries serving up generations-old recipes to cozy cafes dishing out sweet treats and strong coffee, 86th Street offers a delicious journey for every palate. This guide will uncover some of the best places to eat on 86th Street, providing a taste of what makes this Brooklyn gem a must-visit destination for food enthusiasts. Prepare to embark on a culinary adventure – your taste buds will thank you.
Pizza Perfection: A Slice of Heaven on 86th Street
No discussion about food on 86th Street would be complete without mentioning pizza. Pizza isn’t just food here; it’s a way of life. With several pizzerias vying for the title of “best slice,” the competition is fierce, and the rewards are delicious. Let’s explore a few standout contenders.
First stop, Pizza Wagon, a local favorite known for its traditional New York-style pies. Located near Fourth Avenue, Pizza Wagon offers a classic experience. The dough is made fresh daily, the sauce is tangy and perfectly seasoned, and the mozzarella is generous and melty. Order a plain slice for the quintessential experience or venture into specialty pies like their white pizza, loaded with ricotta, garlic, and a drizzle of olive oil. The atmosphere is casual and bustling, perfect for a quick lunch or a satisfying dinner. What sets Pizza Wagon apart is its consistency; every slice is a reminder of why New York pizza is world-renowned. Plus, they are cash only, which keeps it very Brooklyn.
Next, we have Maspeth Pizza, further east down 86th Street. While technically Maspeth Pizza has a location in Maspeth, Queens, this location provides some of the freshest slices of pizza in Bay Ridge. The location allows for ample indoor and outdoor seating. What’s best about this pizzeria is that it’s open late. After a night out, be sure to stop by for a slice of their famous square pizza.
Finally, consider Saints Pizza, a popular spot known for its creative toppings and gourmet approach. They offer classic pies and have several slice options to choose from. Beyond pizza, Saints serves a variety of Italian dishes and sandwiches. The vibe here is modern and upbeat, making it a great choice for a casual meal with friends. What truly differentiates Saints is its commitment to quality ingredients and innovative flavor combinations.
Old World Charm: Indulging in Italian Cuisine
Beyond pizza, Italian food is a cornerstone of the culinary scene on 86th Street. Generations of Italian-American families have shaped the neighborhood, and their culinary traditions are alive and well in the many restaurants that line the street. Prepare for generous portions, warm hospitality, and flavors that transport you straight to Italy.
Tanore Restaurant is a beloved neighborhood institution. Located near 5th Avenue, Tanore has been serving authentic Italian cuisine for decades. The menu features classic dishes like spaghetti carbonara, lasagna, and chicken parmigiana, all prepared with time-honored recipes and the freshest ingredients. The atmosphere is warm and inviting, with red-checkered tablecloths and the comforting aroma of garlic and herbs filling the air. Tanore is special because of its dedication to preserving Italian culinary traditions. A meal here feels like stepping back in time, a taste of the way things used to be.
For a more contemporary take on Italian food, consider Ho’Brah, a trendy restaurant just off 86th Street on Third Avenue. While not technically located on 86th, Ho’Brah brings in people from all over due to the high-quality food and modern aesthetic. The menu features a mix of traditional and innovative dishes, with an emphasis on fresh seafood and seasonal produce. The restaurant’s décor is sleek and stylish, with exposed brick walls and modern lighting. Ho’Brah is special because of its ability to blend classic Italian flavors with contemporary culinary techniques, creating a dining experience that is both familiar and exciting.
Sweet Treats and Coffee: Cafes on 86th
After a savory meal, there’s always room for dessert, and 86th Street has plenty of options to satisfy your sweet tooth. From cozy cafes serving up artisanal pastries to classic bakeries offering traditional Italian treats, there’s something for everyone who craves a little sweetness. And, of course, no dessert is complete without a cup of expertly brewed coffee.
La Bella Marketplace is a popular bakery and cafe right on 86th Street. La Bella is a European-style market and delicatessen. Their cookies are the most popular offering, but the also offer various pasta dishes. What’s special about La Bella is that you can buy the ingredients used to make some of the best cookies on the street.
Another must-visit spot is Starbucks, where you can get one of the chain’s signature coffees or teas. The 86th Street Starbucks is one of the busiest stores in New York City, with several baristas working at once to meet customer demand. This is a great spot to stop by on a chilly day for a pick-me-up.
German Delights: A Taste of Bavaria
While Italian cuisine may dominate, 86th Street in Bay Ridge also offers a delightful taste of Germany. The neighborhood has a strong German heritage, and several restaurants and shops celebrate this tradition with authentic German fare.
Schnitzel Haus is a classic German restaurant that transports you straight to Bavaria. The menu features a wide variety of schnitzels, sausages, and other German specialties. The portions are generous, the beer selection is impressive, and the atmosphere is festive and lively. Schnitzel Haus is special because of its dedication to preserving German culinary traditions and providing a truly authentic dining experience. It’s a great place to celebrate Oktoberfest any time of year.
Practicalities for Exploring Food on 86th Street
Getting to 86th Street is easy. The R train runs directly along 86th Street, with several stops providing convenient access to all the restaurants and shops. Street parking can be challenging, especially during peak hours, so public transportation is highly recommended.
The best time to visit 86th Street is during the day or early evening, when the streets are bustling with activity and the restaurants are at their liveliest. Many restaurants offer outdoor seating during the warmer months, making it a perfect place to enjoy a meal and soak up the neighborhood atmosphere.
The price range for food on 86th Street varies depending on the type of restaurant. Pizza slices can be found for just a few dollars, while a full meal at a more upscale Italian restaurant might cost around twenty to thirty dollars per person.
Most restaurants on 86th Street accept credit cards, but it’s always a good idea to carry some cash, especially for smaller establishments or food carts. Reservations are recommended at some of the more popular restaurants, especially on weekends.
Conclusion: A Flavorful Destination
Food on 86th Street is an experience that goes beyond just satisfying your hunger; it’s about immersing yourself in the culture and community of Bay Ridge. From the classic Italian eateries to the cozy cafes and German restaurants, 86th Street offers a diverse range of culinary delights that are sure to please every palate. So, the next time you’re looking for a delicious adventure, hop on the R train and explore the vibrant food scene on 86th Street. You might just discover your new favorite restaurant or a hidden gem that will keep you coming back for more. 86th Street is a culinary destination worth exploring, a place where food tells a story of tradition, community, and delicious discoveries.
